| Torquay United | | 1990 | | First Round - Group 1 | 07-10-1990 | | Bournemouth | Torquay United | 6-1 | | 1991 | | First Round - Group 1 | 15-09-1991 | | Torquay United | Amazons | 11-0 | | Second Round - Group 1 | 06-10-1991 | | Bristol Backwell | Torquay United | 10-1 | | 1992 | | 1st Round - Group 2 | 13-09-1992 | | Carterton | Torquay United | 1-7 | | 2nd Round - Group 2 | 04-10-1992 | | Newbury | Torquay United | 3-1 | | 1993 | | Second Round | 17-10-1993 | | Torquay United | Truro City | 2-5 | | 1994 | | First Round | 18-09-1994 | | Yate Town | Torquay United | 0-6 | | Second Round | 16-10-1994 | | Torquay United | Eastleigh | 4-1 | | Third Round | 13-11-1994 | | Oxford United | Torquay United | 8-1 | Newton Abbot
| | Moved to Totnes & Dartington in 2006 |  | | 1995 | | First Round | 17-09-1995 | | Newton Abbot | Barry Town | 1-3 | |
|
| 1996 | | First Round | 29-09-1996 | | Worcester City | Newton Abbot | 8-3 | | 1997 | | First Round | 28-09-1997 | | Newton Abbot | Swindon Spitfires | 0-4 | | 1998 | | First Round | 27-09-1998 | | Newton Abbot | Cardiff County | O-W | |
|
| 2001 | | First Round | 28-10-2001 | | Plymouth Argyle | Newton Abbot | 0-6 | | Second Round | 11-11-2001 | | Newton Abbot | Yeovil Town | 0-3 | | 2002 | | First Round | 03-11-2002 | | Newton Abbot | Exeter City | 4-3 | | Second Round | 10-11-2002 | | Newquay | Newton Abbot | 4-2 | | 2003 | | First Round | 26-10-2003 | | Newton Abbot | Plymouth Argyle | 4-0 | | Second Round | 09-11-2003 | | Newton Abbot | Reading | 2-2 | | Second Round | 16-11-2003 | | Reading | Newton Abbot | 4-1 | |
|
| 2004 | | First Round | 08-11-2004 | | Newton Abbot | Forest Green Rovers | 1-1 | | Second Round | 14-11-2004 | | Newton Abbot | Keynsham Town | 1-4 | |
|
| 2005 | | First Round | 23-10-2005 | | Forest Green Rovers | Newton Abbot | 1-0 |
|
|
|