| Peterborough Sports | 
| 2005 | 
| 1st Qualifying Round | 11-09-2005 |  | Bourne United | Peterborough Sports | 1-0 | 
| 2006 | 
| 1st Qualifying Round | 24-09-2006 |  | Kings Sports Luton | Peterborough Sports | 0-2 | 
| 2nd Qualifying Round | 08-10-2006 |  | Peterborough Sports | Peterborough Azure | 0-1 | 
| 2007 | 
| 1st Qualifying Round | 16-09-2007 |  | Peterborough Sports | West Lynn | 4-3 | 
| 2nd Qualifying Round | 30-09-2007 |  | Cambridge United | Peterborough Sports | 0-5 | 
| 3rd Qualifying Round | 07-10-2007 |  | Peterborough Sports | Norwich City | 1-3 | 
| 2008 | 
| Preliminary Round | 07-09-2008 |  | Peterborough Sports | Peterborough Azure | 2-2 | 
| 1st Qualifying Round | 28-09-2008 |  | Peterborough Sports | Hethersett Athletic | 1-0 | 
| 2nd Qualifying Round | 12-10-2008 |  | Peterborough Sports | Woodbridge Town | 2-2 | 
| 3rd Qualifying Round | 26-10-2008 |  | Peterborough Sports | West Lynn | 4-1 | 
| First Round | 09-11-2008 |  | Stoke City | Peterborough Sports | 6-2 | 
|
|
|
| 2009 | 
| 1st Qualifying Round | 27-09-2009 |  | Mansfield Town | Peterborough Sports | 2-1 | 
| 2010 | 
| 2nd Qualifying Round | 24-10-2010 |  | Peterborough Sports | Hucknall Town | W/O | 
| 3rd Qualifying Round | 14-11-2010 |  | Peterborough Sports | Coventry Sphinx | 3-1 | 
| First Round | 12-12-2010 |  | Peterborough Sports | Hemel Hempstead Town | 2-3 | 
|
|
|
|
| 2011 | 
| 1st Qualifying Round | 02-10-2011 |  | Peterborough Sports | Daventry Town | 5-2 | 
| 2nd Qualifying Round | 23-10-2011 |  | Kettering Town | Peterborough Sports | 0-5 | 
| 3rd Qualifying Round | 13-11-2011 |  | Luton Town | Peterborough Sports | 0-1 | 
| First Round | 11-12-2011 |  | Chichester City | Peterborough Sports | 5-2 | 
| Peterborough Sports Parkway | 
| 2012 | 
| 1st Qualifying Round | 30-09-2012 |  | Peterborough Sports Parkway | Raunds Town | 10-0 | 
| 2nd Qualifying Round | 14-10-2012 |  | Peterborough Sports Parkway | Netherton United | 10-1 | 
| 3rd Qualifying Round | 11-11-2012 |  | Peterborough Sports Parkway | C&K Basildon | 3-4 | 
|
|
| 2013 | 
| 1st Qualifying Round | 22-09-2013 |  | Peterborough Sports Parkway | Brackley Sports | 9-0 | 
| 2nd Qualifying Round | 06-10-2013 |  | Lowestoft Town | Peterborough Sports Parkway | 4-0 | 
|  |