Norton
1997
First Round28-09-1997NortonScunthorpe Ironesses 2-2 [1]
First Round05-10-1997Scunthorpe IronessesNorton 3-1
After Extra Time  [1]
1998
First Round27-09-1998NortonStockport County 0-6
1999
Extra Preliminary Round12-09-1999Manchester CityNorton 26-0
Sheffield
2006
Preliminary Round10-09-2006Macclesfield TownSheffield 0-5
1st Qualifying Round24-09-2006SheffieldDarwen 0-2 [1]
AET  [1]
2007
1st Qualifying Round16-09-2007Huddersfield TownSheffield 2-1
2008
Preliminary Round07-09-2008SheffieldBarnsley 1-3
2009
1st Qualifying Round27-09-2009Guiseley AFC VixensSheffield 1-2
2nd Qualifying Round11-10-2009SheffieldMiddleton Athletic 11-0
3rd Qualifying Round25-10-2009SheffieldWhitley Bay 1-2
2010
3rd Qualifying Round14-11-2010SheffieldBradford City 2-0
First Round16-01-2011BarnsleySheffield 0-2
Second Round23-01-2011SheffieldLoughborough Students 1-2
2011
Second Round22-01-2012SheffieldMiddlesbrough 10-0
Third Round19-02-2012PortsmouthSheffield 1-3
Fourth Round26-02-2012Keynsham TownSheffield 5-2
2012
Second Round06-01-2013SheffieldBlackburn Rovers 2-1
Third Round03-02-2013Manchester CitySheffield 3-2
2013
Second Round02-02-2014SheffieldLiverpool Feds 10-0
Third Round16-02-2014Charlton AthleticSheffield 0-6
Fourth Round16-03-2014DurhamSheffield 3-1
2014
Second Round11-01-2015Leicester City WomenSheffield 0-8
Third Round08-02-2015C&K BasildonSheffield 0-5
Fourth Round08-03-2015SheffieldRadcliffe Olympic 4-0
Fifth Round22-03-2015Aston VillaSheffield 2-0
2015
Third Round07-02-2016SheffieldLeicester City Women 5-1
Fourth Round28-02-2016SheffieldSporting Club Albion 1-3
2016
Third Round05-02-2017Charlton AthleticSheffield 0-2
Fourth Round19-02-2017SheffieldDoncaster Rovers Belles 0-1
2017
Fourth Round04-02-2018DurhamSheffield 2-1
2018
Second Round02-12-2018SheffieldNottingham Forest 2-3
2019
Second Round01-12-2019Barnsley WomenSheffield 4-0
2020
Second Round04-04-2021Sunderland AFCSheffield 5-1
2021
First Round14-11-2021SheffieldSutton Coldfield Town 1-1 [1]
Second Round05-12-2021SheffieldHuddersfield Town 0-3 [2]
AET. 1-1 90m. 4-2 penalties  [1]
Switched to Huddersfield Town  [2]
2022
3rd Qualifying Round23-10-2022Lincoln CitySheffield 1-3
First Round13-11-2022Loughborough LightningSheffield 3-0
2023
3rd Qualifying Round22-10-2023Shrewsbury TownSheffield 2-2 [1]
First Round12-11-2023Nottingham ForestSheffield 7-0
Sheffield won 4-3 on penalties  [1]
2024
2nd Qualifying Round22-09-2024AFC Rushden & DiamondsSheffield 1-6
3rd Qualifying Round13-10-2024Oughtibridge War MemorialSheffield 2-3
First Round03-11-2024SheffieldPenrith AFC 2-1
Second Round24-11-2024Shrewsbury TownSheffield 3-3 [1]
Shrewsbury Town won 4-2 on penalties.  [1]