Kilnhurst Shooting Stars
1974
Third Round - Group F01-12-1974Kilnhurst Shooting StarsWallsend W/L [1]
Group Match - Regional Finals05-01-1975Doncaster HammersKilnhurst Shooting Stars 3-2 
Kilnhurst Shooting Stars won  [1]
1975
Second Round - Group 102-11-1975Kilnhurst Shooting StarsBronte 7-0 
Third Round - Group 107-12-1975PrestatynKilnhurst Shooting Stars 3-3 
Third Round - Group 114-12-1975Kilnhurst Shooting StarsPrestatyn ?-? 
1976
First Round - Group F03-10-1976Kilnhurst Shooting StarsDoncaster Belles 5-2 
Group Match - Regional Finals06-02-1977WallsendKilnhurst Shooting Stars ?-? [1]
Quarter Final27-02-1977Queens Park RangersKilnhurst Shooting Stars 5-2 [2]
Kilnhurst Shooting Stars won  [1]
Western Daily Press - Monday 07 March 1977 reported as 5-3  [2]
1977
Second Round02-10-1977BronteKilnhurst Shooting Stars 1-5 
Third Round06-11-1977Kilnhurst Shooting StarsChester 4-0 
Fourth Round04-12-1977Birmingham CityKilnhurst Shooting Stars 1-3 
Fifth Round05-02-1978Kilnhurst Shooting StarsSouthampton 1-3 
Kilnhurst
1978
First Round - Group K05-11-1978KilnhurstRotherham 4-0 
Second Round - Group K03-12-1978BYC Argyle (Burwell Youth Club)Kilnhurst 1-5 
Group Match - Regional Finals14-01-1979Notts RangersKilnhurst 3-2 
1979
First Round - Group O28-10-1979KilnhurstRotherham 4-1 
Second Round - Group O02-12-1979Doncaster BellesKilnhurst 4-2 [1]
Second Round - Group O16-12-1979KilnhurstDoncaster Belles 0-4 
Doncaster fielded an unregistered player, match ordered to be replayed  [1]
1980
First Round - Group G05-10-1980KilnhurstPreston Tigers 20-0 
Second Round - Group G02-11-1980KilnhurstBronte ?-? [1]
Bronte won  [1]
1981
Second Round01-11-1981KilnhurstCleveland Spartans 1-4 
1982
First Round - Group G10-10-1982BP ChemicalsKilnhurst 0-10 
Second Round - Group G07-11-1982RotherhamKilnhurst 2-4 
Third Round - Group G05-12-1982KilnhurstCleveland Spartans 0-1 
1983
First Round - Northern Counties Group02-10-1983KilnhurstSheffield 5-0 
Second Round - Northern Counties Group06-11-1983RowntreeKilnhurst 4-1 
1984
First Round - Group HBye
Second Round - Group H11-11-1984Ingol BellesKilnhurst 2-5 
Third Round - Group H02-12-1984Doncaster BellesKilnhurst 2-0 
1986
First Round - Group E05-10-1986KilnhurstBoots Athletic 5-2 
Second Round - Group E02-11-1986KilnhurstSt Helens 0-8 
1987
First Round - Group EBye
Second Round - Group E04-10-1987SheffieldKilnhurst 2-1 
1993
Second Round17-10-1993City RosesKilnhurst 0-4 
Third Round14-11-1993Cowgate KestrelsKilnhurst 4-1 
1994
First Round18-09-1994Preston RangersKilnhurst 6-1 
1995
First Round17-09-1995Lincoln UnitedKilnhurst 0-4 
Second Round15-10-1995KilnhurstBarnsley 5-1 
Third Round12-11-1995KilnhurstHighfield Rangers 2-4 
Parkgate
2000
First Round29-10-2000IlkestonParkgate 1-2 
Second Round12-11-2000Blackburn RoversParkgate 3-5 
Third Round07-01-2001Mansfield TownParkgate 2-2 [1]
AET. 4-3 on penalties.  [1]
2001
First Round28-10-2001BuryParkgate 3-5 
Second Round11-11-2001NewcastleParkgate 5-2 
2002
First Round03-11-2002ParkgateLiverpool Feds 5-4 
Second Round10-11-2002ParkgateThorpe United 4-1 
Third Round08-12-2002ParkgateAston Villa 2-7 
Rotherham United
2003
First Round26-10-2003Preston North EndRotherham United 5-4 
2005
First Round23-10-2005Rotherham UnitedChester City 6-1 
Second Round13-11-2005Sheffield WednesdayRotherham United 1-2 
Third Round04-12-2005Leeds City VixensRotherham United 5-1 
2006
First Round29-10-2006Bradford CityRotherham United 0-6 
Second Round12-11-2006Rotherham UnitedSalford 4-2 
Third Round03-12-2006Whitley BayRotherham United 2-1 [1]
AET  [1]
2007
Third Round02-12-2007Rotherham UnitedRochdale 6-3 
Fourth Round06-01-2008Rotherham UnitedPortsmouth 3-4 
2008
Third Round21-12-2008Rotherham UnitedYork City 2-1 
Fourth Round04-01-2009ChelseaRotherham United 9-1 
2009
First Round15-11-2009Tranmere RoversRotherham United 1-6 
Second Round13-12-2009Rotherham UnitedLiverpool Feds 2-3 [1]
Venue reversed  [1]
2010
Third Qualifying Round14-11-2010Rotherham UnitedWakefield 3-1 
First Round02-01-2011Daventry TownRotherham United 1-11 
Second Round09-01-2011Derby CountyRotherham United 4-2 
2011
Second Round15-01-2012Blackpool Wren RoversRotherham United 3-4 
Third Round19-02-2012Sunderland AFCRotherham United 8-0 
2012
Third Qualifying Round11-11-2012ChorleyRotherham United 4-1 
2013
Third Qualifying Round03-11-2013NettlehamRotherham United 3-1 
2014
Third Qualifying Round02-11-2014Rotherham UnitedSheffield Wednesday 8-0 
First Round14-12-2014ChorleyRotherham United 5-2 
2015
Third Qualifying Round11-10-2015Rotherham UnitedLong Eaton United 4-5 
2016
Third Qualifying Round09-10-2016Guiseley AFC VixensRotherham United 7-2 
2017
Third Qualifying Round08-10-2017Alnwick Town JuniorsRotherham United 5-0 
2018
Preliminary Round26-08-2018Rotherham UnitedBradford Park Avenue 14-0 
First Qualifying Round02-09-2018Rotherham UnitedBridlington Rovers 1-3 
2019
Preliminary Round01-09-2019Ossett UnitedRotherham United 5-1 
2020
Extra Preliminary Round06-09-2020Rotherham UnitedOughtibridge War Memorial 3-3 [1]
Preliminary Round20-09-2020York CityRotherham United 4-0 
AET. 3-0 Pens  [1]
2021
Second Qualifying Round03-10-2021Rotherham UnitedSheffield Wednesday 4-2 
Third Qualifying Round24-10-2021AFC Telford UnitedRotherham United 3-0 
2022
Second Qualifying Round02-10-2022Rotherham UnitedAltofts 0-2 
2023
Second Qualifying Round01-10-2023Dronfield TownRotherham United 0-2 
Third Qualifying Round22-10-2023Rotherham UnitedLong Itchington 3-2 
First Round12-11-2023Rotherham UnitedWorcester City 0-5