Pelton Newfield
2007
First Qualifying Round16-09-2007Whitley BayPelton Newfield 4-1
Birtley Town
2008
First Qualifying Round28-09-2008Darlington Railway AthleticBirtley Town 5-3
2009
First Qualifying Round27-09-2009Gateshead Rutherford RavensBirtley Town 0-3
Second Qualifying Round11-10-2009Birtley TownWhitley Bay 2-10
2010
First Qualifying Round10-10-2010Norton & Stockton AncientsBirtley Town 2-1
2011
First Qualifying Round02-10-2011RACA TynedaleBirtley Town 3-2
2012
First Qualifying Round30-09-2012North ShieldsBirtley Town 5-2
2013
First Qualifying Round22-09-2013Birtley TownAbbeytown 1-2 [1]
AET  [1]
2014
First Qualifying Round28-09-2014Birtley TownMiddlesbrough Lionesses 4-2
Second Qualifying Round12-10-2014Birtley TownTynedale 0-5
2015
First Qualifying Round06-09-2015Birtley TownLowick United 0-2
2016
Second Qualifying Round18-09-2016Workington RedsBirtley Town 2-1
2020
Extra Preliminary Round06-09-2020Birtley TownBishop Auckland 0-3
2021
First Qualifying Round12-09-2021Birtley TownHartlepool Pools Youth 2-5
2022
First Qualifying Round18-09-2022CullercoatsBirtley Town 0-8
Second Qualifying Round02-10-2022Birtley TownConsett 0-2
2023
First Qualifying Round10-09-2023Gateshead Leam RangersBirtley Town 0-2 [1]
First Qualifying Round17-09-2023Gateshead Leam RangersBirtley Town 1-1 [2]
Second Qualifying Round01-10-2023Washington AFCBirtley Town 0-1
Third Qualifying Round22-10-2023Birtley TownLeeds Modernians 3-3 [3]
Abandoned half-time - thunderstorm  [1]
Birtley Town won 3-0 on penalties  [2]
Leeds Modernians won 5-3 on penalties  [3]