Penrith AFC
2005
First Qualifying Round11-09-2005Penrith AFCWindscale 2-4 [1]
AET  [1]
2006
First Qualifying Round24-09-2006Durham CityPenrith AFC 2-3
Second Qualifying Round08-10-2006Forest HallPenrith AFC 2-4
First Round29-10-2006ChesterfieldPenrith AFC 2-3
Second Round12-11-2006Whitley BayPenrith AFC 2-0
2008
First Qualifying Round28-09-2008Penrith AFCWirral 3-1
Second Qualifying Round12-10-2008Penrith AFCMiddleton Athletic 2-1
Third Qualifying Round26-10-2008Liverpool FedsPenrith AFC 4-0
2010
Second Qualifying Round24-10-2010Penrith AFCBlackpool 3-2
Third Qualifying Round14-11-2010MorecambePenrith AFC 4-3
2011
First Qualifying Round02-10-2011Durham WildcatsPenrith AFC 4-0
2012
Second Qualifying Round14-10-2012Prudhoe TownPenrith AFC 2-5
Third Qualifying Round11-11-2012Penrith AFCMorecambe 2-6
2013
First Qualifying Round22-09-2013Whickham FellsidePenrith AFC 2-2 [1]
Second Qualifying Round06-10-2013Penrith AFCKader 2-2 [2]
AET. 0-3 on penalties.  [1]
AET. 3-4 on penalties.  [2]
2014
First Qualifying Round28-09-2014BlackpoolPenrith AFC 2-3 [1]
Second Qualifying Round12-10-2014WooltonPenrith AFC 1-0
AET  [1]
2015
First Qualifying Round06-09-2015Penrith AFCMiddleton Athletic 3-0
Second Qualifying Round20-09-2015Penrith AFCBurnley 3-3 [1]
Third Qualifying Round11-10-2015Mossley HillPenrith AFC 4-0
AET. 4-3 on penalties.  [1]
2016
Second Qualifying Round18-09-2016Penrith AFCBishop Auckland 1-0 [1]
Third Qualifying Round09-10-2016Penrith AFCBoldon CA 4-2
Fourth Qualifying Round13-11-2016Penrith AFCNorton & Stockton Ancients 0-4
AET  [1]
2017
First Qualifying Round03-09-2017Penrith AFCSouth Park Rangers 4-2
Second Qualifying Round17-09-2017Norton & Stockton AncientsPenrith AFC 3-2 [1]
AET  [1]
2018
First Qualifying Round02-09-2018Penrith AFCWallsend Boys Club 5-1
Second Qualifying Round23-09-2018Brighouse TownPenrith AFC 5-0
2019
Preliminary Round01-09-2019Penrith AFCBishop Auckland 2-4
2020
Preliminary Round20-09-2020CLS AmazonsPenrith AFC 1-2
First Qualifying Round04-10-2020Penrith AFCSouth Shields 1-2
2021
First Qualifying Round12-09-2021Penrith AFCLeam Rangers 7-2
Second Qualifying Round03-10-2021Gateshead RutherfordPenrith AFC 0-2
Third Qualifying Round24-10-2021Alnwick TownPenrith AFC 6-0
2022
First Qualifying Round18-09-2022Penrith AFCCramlington United 6-0
Second Qualifying Round02-10-2022Sunderland West EndPenrith AFC 2-4
Third Qualifying Round23-10-2022Bolton WanderersPenrith AFC 2-2 [1]
First Round13-11-2022Stockport CountyPenrith AFC 7-3
Penrith won 4-2 on penalties  [1]
2023
Second Qualifying Round01-10-2023Workington RedsPenrith AFC 4-5
Third Qualifying Round22-10-2023Penrith AFCMancunian Unity 3-5