Sutton Athletic
1993
First Round19-09-1993Sutton AthleticAbbey Rangers 1-2
1994
First Round18-09-1994Gosport BoroughSutton Athletic 7-2
2022
Second Qualifying Round02-10-2022Leamington LionsSutton Athletic 0-1
Third Qualifying Round23-10-2022Sutton AthleticShifnal Town 1-1 [1]
Sutton Coldfield Town won 5-3 on penalties  [1]