| Sutton United | | 2018 | | Preliminary Round | 23-08-2018 | | Sutton United | AFC Phoenix | 1-2 | | 2019 | | Preliminary Round | 01-09-2019 | | Sutton United | Islington Borough | 0-1 | | 2020 | | Preliminary Round | 20-09-2020 | | Bexhill United | Sutton United | 0-0 | | First Qualifying Round | 11-10-2020 | | Worthing | Sutton United | 6-0 | |
|
| 2021 | | First Qualifying Round | 12-09-2021 | | Sutton United | Meridian | 1-0 | | Second Qualifying Round | 03-10-2021 | | Margate | Sutton United | 1-10 | | Third Qualifying Round | 24-10-2021 | | Welling United | Sutton United | 1-2 | | First Round | 14-11-2021 | | Sutton United | Ashford Town (Middx) | 0-6 | | 2022 | | Second Qualifying Round | 02-10-2022 | | Ashmount Leigh | Sutton United | 0-3 | | Third Qualifying Round | 23-10-2022 | | Herne Bay | Sutton United | 1-2 | | First Round | 13-11-2022 | | Worthing | Sutton United | 8-0 | | 2023 | | Second Qualifying Round | 01-10-2023 | | Leatherhead | Sutton United | 2-4 | | Third Qualifying Round | 22-10-2023 | | Sutton United | Sport London e Benfica | 3-3 | | First Round | 12-11-2023 | | Sutton United | Maidenhead United | 3-4 | |
|
|
|
|
|
