Barnsley
1991
First Round - Group 315-09-1991BarnsleyWakefield 2-5
First Round - Group 815-09-1991Worcester CityBarnsley 4-1
1992
First Round - Group 613-09-1992Hull CityBarnsley 1-0
1993
First Round19-09-1993BarnsleyCleveland 2-3
1994
First Round18-09-1994City RosesBarnsley 2-5
Second Round16-10-1994Huddersfield TownBarnsley 16-0
1995
First Round17-09-1995KirkleesBarnsley 4-4 [1]
First Round24-09-1995BarnsleyKirklees 1-0
Second Round15-10-1995KilnhurstBarnsley 5-1
AET  [1]
1996
First Round29-09-1996Blackburn RoversBarnsley 6-1
1997
First Round28-09-1997Leeds City VixensBarnsley 4-1
1998
First Round27-09-1998Selby TownBarnsley 0-1
Second Round01-11-1998BarnsleyWigan 2-3
1999
Extra Preliminary Round12-09-1999Bolton Wanderers (Supporters)Barnsley 1-0
2000
Extra Preliminary Round10-09-2000ChorleyBarnsley 0-2
Preliminary Round24-09-2000BarnsleyWindscale 1-0
First Round19-11-2000Preston North EndBarnsley 4-2
2001
First Qualifying Round09-09-2001BarnsleyWigan 3-0
Second Qualifying Round30-09-2001BarnsleyOssett Albion 7-0
First Round28-10-2001Manchester UnitedBarnsley 2-1
2002
First Round03-11-2002Preston North EndBarnsley 2-3
Second Round10-11-2002Blackburn RoversBarnsley 4-0
2003
First Round26-10-2003Chester CityBarnsley 2-0
2004
Second Qualifying Round26-09-2004Bury Girls & LadiesBarnsley 1-1 [1]
AET. 4-1 on penalties.  [1]
2005
First Qualifying Round11-09-2005BarnsleyDarlington Railway Athletic 5-0
Second Qualifying Round25-09-2005WindscaleBarnsley 1-3
First Round23-10-2005BarnsleyBlyth Spartans 1-2
2006
Preliminary Round10-09-2006Morley SpursBarnsley 2-1
2007
First Qualifying Round16-09-2007BarnsleyOssett Albion 3-1
Second Qualifying Round30-09-2007Brighouse TownBarnsley 1-5
Third Qualifying Round07-10-2007BarnsleyRadcliffe Olympic 0-1
2008
Preliminary Round07-09-2008SheffieldBarnsley 1-3
First Qualifying Round28-09-2008BarnsleyKeighley AFC 5-0
Second Qualifying Round12-10-2008BarnsleyGuiseley AFC Vixens 2-3
2009
First Qualifying Round27-09-2009BarnsleyHull City 1-2 [1]
AET  [1]
2010
Second Qualifying Round24-10-2010BarnsleySteel City Wanderers 2-0
Third Qualifying Round14-11-2010BarnsleyScunthorpe United 3-2
First Round16-01-2011BarnsleySheffield 0-2
2011
First Qualifying Round02-10-2011BarnsleyOssett Albion 9-0
Second Qualifying Round23-10-2011BarnsleyKeighley Oaks 5-3
Third Qualifying Round13-11-2011Durham WildcatsBarnsley 3-0
2012
First Qualifying Round30-09-2012BarnsleyBrighouse Town 3-0
Second Qualifying Round14-10-2012Guiseley AFC VixensBarnsley 1-3
Third Qualifying Round11-11-2012BarnsleyLiverpool Feds 1-2
2017
Third Qualifying Round08-10-2017Chester Le Street TownBarnsley 2-1
Barnsley Women
2018
Second Qualifying Round23-09-2018Barnsley WomenNewcastle United 2-3 [1]
AET  [1]
2019
Second Qualifying Round06-10-2019Barnsley WomenBradford City 5-1
Third Qualifying Round27-10-2019Leeds UnitedBarnsley Women 0-3
First Round10-11-2019Crewe AlexandraBarnsley Women 1-2
Second Round01-12-2019Barnsley WomenSheffield 4-0
Third Round05-01-2020Brighouse TownBarnsley Women 0-1
Fourth Round26-01-2020Tottenham HotspurBarnsley Women 5-0
2020
Second Qualifying Round18-10-2020Blyth TownBarnsley Women 0-5
Third Qualifying Round01-11-2020Barnsley WomenLeeds United 4-1
First Round13-12-2020Newcastle UnitedBarnsley Women 3-1
2021
Third Qualifying Round24-10-2021Barnsley WomenSalford City Lionesses 3-0 [1]
Salford awarded the tie as Barnsley played an ineligible player.  [1]
2022
Third Qualifying Round23-10-2022Blackburn Community Sports ClubBarnsley Women 0-6
First Round13-11-2022DarwenBarnsley Women 1-5
Second Round27-11-2022Newcastle UnitedBarnsley Women 2-1
2023
Second Qualifying Round01-10-2023Barnsley WomenOssett United 1-3
Third Qualifying Round22-10-2023WythenshaweBarnsley Women 2-3
First Round12-11-2023Barnsley WomenLiverpool Feds 0-3