St Albans City
2010
First Qualifying Round03-10-2010WestSt Albans City 3-2 [1]
Hannakins?  [1]
2012
First Qualifying Round30-09-2012Royston TownSt Albans City 0-1
Second Qualifying Round14-10-2012BarkingSt Albans City 6-1
2013
First Qualifying Round22-09-2013Sawbridgeworth TownSt Albans City 1-2
Second Qualifying Round06-10-2013St Albans CityWaveney Wanderers 5-0
Third Qualifying Round03-11-2013Enfield TownSt Albans City 6-2
Colney Heath
2014
First Qualifying Round28-09-2014GarstonColney Heath 1-3
Second Qualifying Round12-10-2014Leighton United VixensColney Heath 4-1
2015
First Qualifying Round06-09-2015GarstonColney Heath 1-2
Second Qualifying Round20-09-2015Hemel Hempstead TownColney Heath 4-2
2016
Second Qualifying Round18-09-2016Colney HeathRoyston Town 1-3
2017
First Qualifying Round03-09-2017GarstonColney Heath 1-4
Second Qualifying Round17-09-2017Colney HeathRoyston Town 0-4
2018
Preliminary Round19-08-2018Colney HeathHemel Hempstead Town 7-0
First Qualifying Round02-09-2018Colney HeathHoughton Athletic 2-0
Second Qualifying Round23-09-2018Billericay TownColney Heath 9-1
2019
Preliminary Round01-09-2019BedfordColney Heath 1-3
First Qualifying Round22-09-2019Colney HeathRoyston Town 2-5
2020
Extra Preliminary Round06-09-2020Colney HeathHerts Vipers 2-1
Preliminary Round20-09-2020Colney HeathHarlow Town 3-4
2021
Second Qualifying Round03-10-2021Leigh RamblersColney Heath 3-0
2022
Second Qualifying Round02-10-2022Wootton Blue CrossColney Heath 3-5
Third Qualifying Round30-10-2022Colney HeathCambridge City 1-0
First Round13-11-2022Colney HeathHashtag United 1-10
St Albans City
2023
Second Qualifying Round01-10-2023Royston TownSt Albans City 2-1