| Horley Town | | 2006 | | Preliminary Round | 10-09-2006 | | Bexhill United | Horley Town | 2-4 | | First Qualifying Round | 24-09-2006 | | Horley Town | Sheerness East | 1-3 | | 2007 | | First Qualifying Round | 16-09-2007 | | Horley Town | East Preston | 3-3 | | Second Qualifying Round | 30-09-2007 | | Aldershot Town | Horley Town | 1-6 | | Third Qualifying Round | 07-10-2007 | | Petts Wood | Horley Town | 2-1 | |
|
|
| 2008 | | Preliminary Round | 14-09-2008 | | Horley Town | Bisley | 3-2 | | First Qualifying Round | 28-09-2008 | | Shanklin | Horley Town | 1-1 | | Second Qualifying Round | 12-10-2008 | | Horley Town | Aldershot Town | 5-1 | | Third Qualifying Round | 26-10-2008 | | Horley Town | Havant & Waterlooville | 0-5 | |
|
| 2009 | | First Qualifying Round | 27-09-2009 | | AFC Wimbledon | Horley Town | 3-1 | | Dorking | | 2010 | | Second Qualifying Round | 24-10-2010 | | Westfield | Dorking | 9-1 | |
|
|
|
|
