Gateshead
2021
First Qualifying Round12-09-2021Guisborough TownGateshead 0-12
Second Qualifying Round03-10-2021GatesheadSpennymoor Town 2-1
Third Qualifying Round24-10-2021GatesheadHarrogate Town AFC 0-2
2022
First Qualifying Round18-09-2022Gateshead RutherfordGateshead 3-0
2023
Second Qualifying Round01-10-2023ThornabyGateshead 1-2
Third Qualifying Round22-10-2023GatesheadHartlepool United 3-1
First Round12-11-2023GatesheadAlnwick Town 1-2 [1]
After Extra Time, 1-1 after 90 minutes  [1]