Gateshead Rutherford
2020
Preliminary Round20-09-2020South ShieldsGateshead Rutherford 3-1
2021
Second Qualifying Round03-10-2021Gateshead RutherfordPenrith AFC 0-2
2022
First Qualifying Round18-09-2022Gateshead RutherfordGateshead 3-0
Second Qualifying Round02-10-2022Gateshead RutherfordCarlisle United 2-0
Third Qualifying Round23-10-2022Newcastle UnitedGateshead Rutherford 12-0 [1]
Third Qualifying Round30-10-2022Gateshead RutherfordNewcastle United O-W [2]
Replay ordered after Newcastle United used too many substitutes  [1]
Gateshead Rutherford withdrew  [2]
2023
First Qualifying Round10-09-2023Gateshead RutherfordThornaby 1-2 [1]
First Qualifying Round17-09-2023Gateshead RutherfordThornaby 0-1
Abandoned 49 minutes - thunderstorm  [1]